FormulaSeek - Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF vs Enfamil Nutramigen
Updated: 12/7/2024
Introduction
Choosing the right infant formula is crucial for a baby's growth and development. With numerous options available, parents often face a daunting task. Two popular choices in the market are Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF and Enfamil Nutramigen. Both of these formulas are specially designed for babies with specific dietary needs or sensitivities. This blog post will provide an in-depth comparison of these two products to help parents make informed decisions.
Nutritional Composition
The nutritional composition of infant formulas is a key factor in selecting the right product for an infant's dietary needs. Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF is formulated with partially hydrolyzed whey protein, making it easier to digest for some infants. The primary carbohydrate source is corn maltodextrin, and the fat profile includes high oleic safflower oil, soy oil, and coconut oil. It also includes essential vitamins and minerals required for infant development.
In contrast, Enfamil Nutramigen utilizes extensively hydrolyzed casein protein, which helps in managing cow's milk allergy symptoms. The main carbohydrate source is corn syrup solids, and its fat content is derived from safflower oil, soy oil, and coconut oil. Like Similac, it provides essential vitamins and minerals but varies in specific nutrient concentrations to support infants with sensitivity or allergies.
Key Differences
| Feature | Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF | Enfamil Nutramigen |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Source | Partially hydrolyzed whey | Extensively hydrolyzed casein |
| Carbohydrate Source | Corn maltodextrin | Corn syrup solids |
| Fat Source | Safflower oil, soy oil, coconut oil | Safflower oil, soy oil, coconut oil |
| Prebiotics and Probiotics | Contains 2'-FL HMO | Contains LGG Probiotic |
| Omega-3 (DHA/ARA) | Yes | Yes |
| Iron and Calcium Content | Varied | Varied |
| Estimated Cost per Ounce | $0.20 (estimated) | $0.30 (estimated) |
| Certification | Non-GMO | Non-GMO |
Special Features and Benefits
Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF is particularly beneficial for infants with mild digestive discomfort due to its gentle formulation and inclusion of 2'-FL HMO prebiotic for immune support. Enfamil Nutramigen stands out for its extensively hydrolyzed proteins that help manage cows’ milk allergy symptoms and inclusion of LGG probiotic to support digestive health.
Target Audience
Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF is suitable for babies who experience mild digestive issues or discomfort. It provides relief with its partially hydrolyzed protein. Enfamil Nutramigen, on the other hand, targets infants with severe lactose sensitivities or allergies, offering a more specialized solution through its extensively broken-down proteins and added probiotic.
Alternatives
Alternatives to Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF
- Gerber Good Start Soy
- Earth's Best Organic Sensitivity
- Happy Baby Sensitive
- Parent's Choice Sensitivity
- Enfamil Gentlease
Alternatives to Enfamil Nutramigen
- Similac Alimentum
- Gerber Extensive HA
- Happy Baby Organic
- Nutricia Neocate
- PurAmino Hypoallergenic
Potential Drawbacks
Both formulas are considerably more expensive than standard infant formulas, with Enfamil Nutramigen being particularly high-priced. Availability can vary based on location and demand. Additionally, some critics argue against the inclusion of certain ingredients like palm oil, which may affect calcium absorption.
Conclusion
In conclusion, choosing between Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF and Enfamil Nutramigen depends largely on the specific dietary needs and sensitivities of the baby. Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF is a solid choice for mild digestive issues, while Enfamil Nutramigen is more suited for severe allergies. Parents should weigh the benefits against potential drawbacks, such as cost and ingredient considerations, and consult with a pediatrician to determine the best option for their infant’s nutritional requirements.
Sources*
Buy Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF Online
Buy Enfamil Nutramigen Online
+ Links are reviewed periodically for accuracy; failing links might mean the product is currently unavailable.
Start here
Nutrient comparison
| Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF | +/- | Data | +/- | Enfamil Nutramigen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.40 g | 0.10 | Fat | 5.30 g | |
| 10.70 g | 0.40 | Carbohydrate | 10.30 g | |
| 2.32 g | Protein | 0.48 | 2.80 g | |
| 1000.00 mg | 220.00 | Linoleic Acid | 780.00 mg |
Ingredient comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
Minerals comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
| Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF | +/- | Minerals | +/- | Enfamil Nutramigen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 105.00 mg | 11.00 | Calcium | -11.00 | 94.00 mg |
| 75.00 mg | 23.00 | Phosphorus | -23.00 | 52.00 mg |
| 6.00 mg | -2.00 | Magnesium | 2.00 | 8.00 mg |
| 1.80 mg | 0.00 | Iron | 0.00 | 1.80 mg |
| 0.75 mg | -0.25 | Zinc | 0.25 | 1.00 mg |
| 5.00 mcg | -20.00 | Manganese | 20.00 | 25.00 mcg |
| 90.00 mcg | 15.00 | Copper | -15.00 | 75.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Iodine | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 2.00 mcg | -0.80 | Selenium | 0.80 | 2.80 mcg |
| 44.00 mg | -3.00 | Sodium | 3.00 | 47.00 mg |
| 118.00 mg | 8.00 | Potassium | -8.00 | 110.00 mg |
| 65.00 mg | -21.00 | Chloride | 21.00 | 86.00 mg |
Vitamins comparison
Vitamins from both formulas are listed in the center. If they exist in a formula they will have a value next to them. The difference will be show under the +/- column for easy visibility.
| Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF | +/- | Vitamin | +/- | Enfamil Nutramigen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24.00 mg | Inositol | |||
| 1.50 IU | -0.50 | Vitamin E | 0.50 | 2.00 IU |
| 8.00 mcg | -1.00 | Vitamin K | 1.00 | 9.00 mcg |
| 100.00 mcg | 20.00 | Thiamin (Vit B1) | -20.00 | 80.00 mcg |
| 150.00 mcg | 60.00 | Riboflavin (Vit B2) | -60.00 | 90.00 mcg |
| 60.00 mcg | 0.00 | Vitamin B6 | 0.00 | 60.00 mcg |
| 0.25 mcg | -0.05 | Vitamin B12 | 0.05 | 0.30 mcg |
| 1050.00 mcg | 50.00 | Niacin | -50.00 | 1000.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | -1.00 | Folic Acid | 1.00 | 16.00 mcg |
| 450.00 mcg | -50.00 | Pantothenic Acid | 50.00 | 500.00 mcg |
| 4.40 mcg | 1.40 | Biotin | -1.40 | 3.00 mg |
| 9.00 mg | -3.00 | Vitamin C | 3.00 | 12.00 mg |
| 24.00 mg | 0.00 | Choline | 0.00 | 24.00 mg |
| 300.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin A | 0.00 | 300.00 IU |
| 60.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin D | 0.00 | 60.00 IU |