FormulaSeek - Similac ProTotal Comfort vs Similac Alimentum RTF
Updated: 12/7/2024
Introduction
Choosing the right infant formula is crucial for your baby's growth and development. With so many options available, making an informed decision can be overwhelming. Two popular choices among parents are Similac Alimentum RTF and Similac ProTotal Comfort. While both are trusted brands, they cater to different dietary needs and sensitivities. This blog will delve into the specific features and benefits of each, helping you make the best choice for your little one.
Nutritional Composition
Similac Alimentum RTF and Similac ProTotal Comfort are both formulated to provide complete nutrition for infants, yet they have distinct nutritional compositions. Similac Alimentum RTF is a ready-to-feed formula designed for infants with severe food allergies, colic due to protein sensitivity, or lactose intolerance. It features extensively hydrolyzed casein protein, providing easier digestion for sensitive tummies. In contrast, Similac ProTotal Comfort contains partially hydrolyzed whey protein. This makes it a more gentle option for infants with mild gastrointestinal discomfort or gas.
The carbohydrate source in Similac Alimentum is corn syrup solids, whereas Similac ProTotal Comfort utilizes a combination of lactose and maltodextrin. Both formulas offer a blend of fats using ingredients like safflower oil and soy oil, but ProTotal Comfort also includes palm olein oil.
When it comes to vitamins and minerals, both formulas cover the basic nutritional needs, but their specific concentrations and additional components like prebiotics and probiotics vary.
Key Differences
| Feature | Similac Alimentum RTF | Similac ProTotal Comfort |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Source | Extensively hydrolyzed casein | Partially hydrolyzed whey |
| Carbohydrate Source | Corn syrup solids | Lactose, maltodextrin |
| Fat Source | Safflower oil, soy oil | Palm olein oil, soy oil, coconut oil |
| Prebiotics and Probiotics | None | 2’-FL HMO prebiotic |
| Omega-3 (DHA/ARA) Levels | Present | Enhanced with DHA |
| Iron and Calcium Content | Standard | Enhanced |
| Estimated Cost per Ounce | $0.60* | $0.55* |
| Organic or Non-GMO Certification | Non-GMO | Non-GMO |
*Prices are estimated and may vary by location and retailer.
Special Features and Benefits
Similac Alimentum RTF is designed for infants with severe allergies or sensitivities. Its hydrolyzed protein helps reduce colic symptoms in some infants within 24 hours. On the other hand, Similac ProTotal Comfort is known for its gentle, partially hydrolyzed protein, making digestion easier. Additionally, its HMO prebiotic enhances immune support, mimicking those found in breast milk.
Target Audience
Similac Alimentum RTF is optimal for babies experiencing food allergies or protein sensitivity. It is particularly beneficial for those with conditions leading to severe gastrointestinal distress. Similac ProTotal Comfort suits babies with milder digestive issues or lactose sensitivity, providing a softer digestive experience without compromising nutritional value.
Alternatives
Alternatives to Similac Alimentum RTF
- Nutramigen Hypoallergenic Infant Formula
- Gerber Extensive HA
- Enfamil PurAmino Hypoallergenic Formula
- EleCare Infant Formula
- Neocate Infant DHA/ARA
Alternatives to Similac ProTotal Comfort
- Enfamil Gentlease
- Gerber Good Start Gentle
- Earth's Best Organic Gentle Infant Formula
- Happy Baby Organic Superfood Infant Formula
- Mama Bear Gentle Infant Formula
Potential Drawbacks
Similac Alimentum RTF's higher price might be a concern for some families, and its availability can sometimes be limited in retail. For Similac ProTotal Comfort, the presence of palm olein oil is controversial, as it might affect fat absorption in some infants. It's essential to consult with healthcare professionals if you're worried about any effects your baby might experience.
Conclusion
Both Similac Alimentum RTF and Similac ProTotal Comfort have strong points for different infant needs. Similac Alimentum is ideal for infants with severe allergies or sensitivities, whereas Similac ProTotal Comfort is designed for milder digestive concerns. Regardless of the choice, always consult with a pediatrician to ensure the selected formula meets your baby’s specific nutritional and developmental requirements.
Sources*
Buy Similac ProTotal Comfort Online
Buy Similac Alimentum RTF Online
+ Links are reviewed periodically for accuracy; failing links might mean the product is currently unavailable.
Start here
Nutrient comparison
| Similac ProTotal Comfort | +/- | Data | +/- | Similac Alimentum RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.40 g | Fat | 0.14 | 5.54 g | |
| 10.70 g | 0.50 | Carbohydrate | 10.20 g | |
| 2.32 g | Protein | 0.43 | 2.75 g | |
| 1000.00 mg | Linoleic Acid | 900.00 | 1900.00 mg |
Ingredient comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
Minerals comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
| Similac ProTotal Comfort | +/- | Minerals | +/- | Similac Alimentum RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 105.00 mg | 0.00 | Calcium | 0.00 | 105.00 mg |
| 75.00 mg | 0.00 | Phosphorus | 0.00 | 75.00 mg |
| 6.00 mg | -1.50 | Magnesium | 1.50 | 7.50 mg |
| 1.80 mg | 0.00 | Iron | 0.00 | 1.80 mg |
| 0.75 mg | 0.00 | Zinc | 0.00 | 0.75 mg |
| 5.00 mcg | -3.00 | Manganese | 3.00 | 8.00 mcg |
| 90.00 mcg | 15.00 | Copper | -15.00 | 75.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Iodine | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 2.00 mcg | 0.00 | Selenium | 0.00 | 2.00 mcg |
| 44.00 mg | 0.00 | Sodium | 0.00 | 44.00 mg |
| 118.00 mg | 0.00 | Potassium | 0.00 | 118.00 mg |
| 65.00 mg | -15.00 | Chloride | 15.00 | 80.00 mg |
Vitamins comparison
Vitamins from both formulas are listed in the center. If they exist in a formula they will have a value next to them. The difference will be show under the +/- column for easy visibility.
| Similac ProTotal Comfort | +/- | Vitamin | +/- | Similac Alimentum RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.50 IU | -1.50 | Vitamin E | 1.50 | 3.00 IU |
| 8.00 mcg | -7.00 | Vitamin K | 7.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 100.00 mcg | 40.00 | Thiamin (Vit B1) | -40.00 | 60.00 mcg |
| 150.00 mcg | 60.00 | Riboflavin (Vit B2) | -60.00 | 90.00 mcg |
| 60.00 mcg | 0.00 | Vitamin B6 | 0.00 | 60.00 mcg |
| 0.25 mcg | -0.20 | Vitamin B12 | 0.20 | 0.45 mcg |
| 1050.00 mcg | -300.00 | Niacin | 300.00 | 1350.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Folic Acid | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 450.00 mcg | -300.00 | Pantothenic Acid | 300.00 | 750.00 mcg |
| 4.40 mcg | -0.10 | Biotin | 0.10 | 4.50 mcg |
| 9.00 mg | 0.00 | Vitamin C | 0.00 | 9.00 mg |
| 24.00 mg | 12.00 | Choline | -12.00 | 12.00 mg |
| 24.00 mg | 19.00 | Inositol | -19.00 | 5.00 mg |
| 300.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin A | 0.00 | 300.00 IU |
| 60.00 IU | 15.00 | Vitamin D | -15.00 | 45.00 IU |