FormulaSeek - Similac Alimentum RTF vs Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF
Updated: 12/7/2024
Introduction
Choosing the right infant formula is a crucial decision for many parents as it plays a significant role in an infant's early development and health. With a myriad of options on the market, selecting the best formula to suit a child's specific needs can be challenging. Two popular options are Similac Alimentum RTF (Ready-to-Feed) and Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF, both specially formulated for infants with specific dietary needs. This post aims to compare these two formulas to guide parents in making an informed decision.
Nutritional Composition
Similac Alimentum RTF: This formula is known for its hypoallergenic properties, making it suitable for babies with milk allergies or intolerances. The protein is extensively hydrolyzed casein, making it easier for sensitive stomachs to digest. The carbohydrate source is primarily corn maltodextrin, and it uses a blend of oils, including medium chain triglycerides (MCT) oil, high oleic safflower oil, and soy oil.
Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF: This formula features partially hydrolyzed whey protein to support easier digestion, especially for babies who experience discomfort with traditional formulas. Lactose is used as the primary carbohydrate source, supplemented with corn maltodextrin. The fat is derived from high oleic safflower oil, soy oil, and coconut oil. Additionally, it includes 2'-FL HMO, a prebiotic similar to one found in breast milk, to support a healthy gut and immune system.
Key Differences
| Feature | Similac Alimentum RTF | Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Source | Extensively hydrolyzed casein | Partially hydrolyzed whey protein |
| Carbohydrate Source | Corn maltodextrin | Lactose, corn maltodextrin |
| Fat Source | MCT oil, high oleic safflower oil, soy oil | High oleic safflower oil, soy oil, coconut oil |
| Prebiotics/Probiotics | None | 2'-FL HMO Prebiotic |
| Omega-3 Levels | Contains DHA/ARA | Contains DHA/ARA |
| Iron and Calcium Content | Sufficient levels for infant growth | Sufficient levels for infant growth |
| Estimated Cost per Ounce | Approximately $0.60 (prices may vary) | Approximately $0.50 (prices may vary) |
| Organic or Non-GMO Certification | Non-GMO | Non-GMO |
Special Features and Benefits
Similac Alimentum RTF is specially designed for infants with food allergies or colic due to protein sensitivity, using an extensively hydrolyzed protein to minimize allergic reactions. Moreover, its lack of artificial growth hormones aligns with parental concerns about ingredients.
Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF boasts partially hydrolyzed protein, which supports easier digestion for babies who experience gassiness, fussiness, or mild discomfort with standard formulas. The inclusion of the 2'-FL HMO prebiotic is intended to strengthen the infant's immune system by mimicking the benefits of breast milk.
Target Audience
Similac Alimentum RTF is aimed at infants who have shown allergy symptoms to regular cow's milk protein or are suffering from severe colic due to protein sensitivity. It’s also ideal for parents seeking a formula that reduces such allergens.
Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF serves babies who have mild digestive discomfort with traditional formulas. It's designed for infants needing a gentler formula with additional immune support, thereby benefiting those with a history of digestive distress.
Alternatives
Alternatives to Similac Alimentum RTF
- Enfamil Nutramigen
- Gerber Extensive HA
- Earth's Best Organic Sensitivity
- Happy Baby Organic Superfood Puffs
- EleCare Infant Formula
Alternatives to Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF
- Enfamil Gentlease
- Gerber Good Start Soothe
- Earth's Best Organic Gentle Formula
- Parent's Choice Gentle Formula
- Happy Baby Organic Sensitive Formula
Potential Drawbacks
One of the potential drawbacks of Similac Alimentum RTF is its relatively higher cost compared to standard formulas, which may be a concern for budget-conscious families. Additionally, availability can sometimes be an issue in certain areas.
While Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF addresses mild digestive discomfort, it might not be suitable for infants with severe protein allergies or sensitivities. Additionally, some parents may have concerns regarding the use of corn derivatives in its composition.
Conclusion
Both Similac Alimentum RTF and Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF offer specialized nutrition for infants with specific dietary needs. Alimentum is the clear choice for infants with severe allergies, whereas ProTotal Comfort serves those who require gentle digestion support. Parents must evaluate their infant's specific needs and consult with a pediatrician to ensure the chosen formula supports optimal health and development.
Sources*
Buy Similac Alimentum RTF Online
Buy Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF Online
+ Links are reviewed periodically for accuracy; failing links might mean the product is currently unavailable.
Start here
Nutrient comparison
| Similac Alimentum RTF | +/- | Data | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.54 g | 0.14 | Fat | 5.40 g | |
| 10.20 g | Carbohydrate | 0.50 | 10.70 g | |
| 2.75 g | 0.43 | Protein | 2.32 g | |
| 1900.00 mg | 900.00 | Linoleic Acid | 1000.00 mg |
Ingredient comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
Minerals comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
| Similac Alimentum RTF | +/- | Minerals | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 105.00 mg | 0.00 | Calcium | 0.00 | 105.00 mg |
| 75.00 mg | 0.00 | Phosphorus | 0.00 | 75.00 mg |
| 7.50 mg | 1.50 | Magnesium | -1.50 | 6.00 mg |
| 1.80 mg | 0.00 | Iron | 0.00 | 1.80 mg |
| 0.75 mg | 0.00 | Zinc | 0.00 | 0.75 mg |
| 8.00 mcg | 3.00 | Manganese | -3.00 | 5.00 mcg |
| 75.00 mcg | -15.00 | Copper | 15.00 | 90.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Iodine | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 2.00 mcg | 0.00 | Selenium | 0.00 | 2.00 mcg |
| 44.00 mg | 0.00 | Sodium | 0.00 | 44.00 mg |
| 118.00 mg | 0.00 | Potassium | 0.00 | 118.00 mg |
| 80.00 mg | 15.00 | Chloride | -15.00 | 65.00 mg |
Vitamins comparison
Vitamins from both formulas are listed in the center. If they exist in a formula they will have a value next to them. The difference will be show under the +/- column for easy visibility.
| Similac Alimentum RTF | +/- | Vitamin | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort RTF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin A | 0.00 | 300.00 IU |
| 45.00 IU | -15.00 | Vitamin D | 15.00 | 60.00 IU |
| 3.00 IU | 1.50 | Vitamin E | -1.50 | 1.50 IU |
| 15.00 mcg | 7.00 | Vitamin K | -7.00 | 8.00 mcg |
| 60.00 mcg | -40.00 | Thiamin (Vit B1) | 40.00 | 100.00 mcg |
| 90.00 mcg | -60.00 | Riboflavin (Vit B2) | 60.00 | 150.00 mcg |
| 60.00 mcg | 0.00 | Vitamin B6 | 0.00 | 60.00 mcg |
| 0.45 mcg | 0.20 | Vitamin B12 | -0.20 | 0.25 mcg |
| 1350.00 mcg | 300.00 | Niacin | -300.00 | 1050.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Folic Acid | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 750.00 mcg | 300.00 | Pantothenic Acid | -300.00 | 450.00 mcg |
| 4.50 mcg | 0.10 | Biotin | -0.10 | 4.40 mcg |
| 9.00 mg | 0.00 | Vitamin C | 0.00 | 9.00 mg |
| 12.00 mg | -12.00 | Choline | 12.00 | 24.00 mg |
| 5.00 mg | -19.00 | Inositol | 19.00 | 24.00 mg |