FormulaSeek - Enfamil Nutramigen vs Similac ProTotal Comfort
Updated: 12/7/2024
Introduction
Choosing the right infant formula is crucial for the healthy growth and development of your baby, especially when breastfeeding is not an option. Among the myriad options available, two well-regarded formulas stand out: Similac ProTotal Comfort and Enfamil Nutramigen. These formulas are designed to meet specific needs, offering tailored nutrition for different digestive and dietary sensitivities. In this blog, we will delve into the differences and benefits of these two brands to help guide your choice.
Nutritional Composition
Similac ProTotal Comfort is formulated with partially hydrolyzed protein for easier digestion. It uses whey protein and includes 2'-FL HMO prebiotic, which mimics some of the immune benefits of breast milk. The carbohydrate source primarily consists of corn maltodextrin, and it incorporates a fat blend devoid of palm olein oil to promote calcium absorption.
Enfamil Nutramigen, on the other hand, offers extensively hydrolyzed casein protein for babies with severe allergies or lactose intolerance. It uses corn syrup solids as a carbohydrate source. The formula includes a fat blend with MCT oils that aid digestion, and it is enriched with DHA and ARA for brain and eye development.
Key Differences
| Feature | Similac ProTotal Comfort | Enfamil Nutramigen |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Source | Partially Hydrolyzed Whey | Extensively Hydrolyzed Casein |
| Carbohydrate Source | Corn Maltodextrin | Corn Syrup Solids |
| Fat Source | No Palm Olein Oil | With MCT Oils |
| Prebiotics and Probiotics | 2'-FL HMO Prebiotic | Lactobacillus GG Probiotic |
| Omega-3 DHA Levels | Included | Included |
| Iron and Calcium Content | Included | Included |
| Estimated Cost per Ounce | ~$0.25 | ~$0.50 |
| Organic or non-GMO Certification | Non-GMO | Non-GMO |
Special Features and Benefits
Similac ProTotal Comfort provides partially hydrolyzed protein, making it suitable for sensitive tummies. Its inclusion of 2'-FL HMO prebiotic aids in nurturing your baby’s developing immune system. Without palm olein oil, it also promotes better calcium absorption for stronger bones.
Enfamil Nutramigen is crafted for babies with severe allergies such as milk protein allergy. The extensively hydrolyzed protein makes it easier to digest and helps alleviate allergic reactions. Additionally, its MCT oil content simplifies fat digestion, beneficial for infants with specific gastrointestinal conditions. It also includes probiotics to further support digestive health.
Target Audience
Similac ProTotal Comfort is best for infants who experience fussiness and gas due to lactose sensitivity or need a gentler formula to soothe their digestive system.
Enfamil Nutramigen is ideal for babies with milk protein allergies or severe food allergies, especially those who have displayed a sensitivity to lactose.
Alternatives
Alternatives to Similac ProTotal Comfort
- Gerber Good Start GentlePro
- Enfamil Gentlease
- Earth’s Best Organic Sensitivity
- Happy Baby Organics Sensitive
- Parent’s Choice Tender
Alternatives to Enfamil Nutramigen
- Similac Alimentum
- Gerber Extensive HA
- EleCare Hypoallergenic Infant Formula
- PurAmino Hypoallergenic
- Neocate Infant DHA/ARA
Potential Drawbacks
Similac ProTotal Comfort can be slightly more affordable, but some parents may find it lacks the specialized proteins required for severe allergy cases. Additionally, individual tolerance varies, and not every baby may respond favorably to its composition.
Enfamil Nutramigen is quite effective for babies with allergies, but its cost is significantly higher. Also, some parents point out taste differences that may lead to acceptance issues by some infants.
Conclusion
Both Similac ProTotal Comfort and Enfamil Nutramigen cater to specific needs and offer unique benefits for different infant dietary challenges. Similac ProTotal Comfort is excellent for babies with mild sensitivities, offering additional immune support through prebiotics. Enfamil Nutramigen, with its extensive hydrolysis of proteins, is suited for infants with severe allergies. As always, it is paramount to consult with a pediatrician to determine the best formula for your baby's specific needs and health conditions.
Note: Prices mentioned are estimated and may vary depending on retailer and location.
Sources*
Buy Enfamil Nutramigen Online
Buy Similac ProTotal Comfort Online
+ Links are reviewed periodically for accuracy; failing links might mean the product is currently unavailable.
Start here
Nutrient comparison
| Enfamil Nutramigen | +/- | Data | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.30 g | Fat | 0.10 | 5.40 g | |
| 10.30 g | Carbohydrate | 0.40 | 10.70 g | |
| 2.80 g | 0.48 | Protein | 2.32 g | |
| 780.00 mg | Linoleic Acid | 220.00 | 1000.00 mg |
Ingredient comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
Minerals comparison
Items in the left column are unique to that formula, same for the right. Items in the middle are in both.
| Enfamil Nutramigen | +/- | Minerals | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 94.00 mg | -11.00 | Calcium | 11.00 | 105.00 mg |
| 52.00 mg | -23.00 | Phosphorus | 23.00 | 75.00 mg |
| 8.00 mg | 2.00 | Magnesium | -2.00 | 6.00 mg |
| 1.80 mg | 0.00 | Iron | 0.00 | 1.80 mg |
| 1.00 mg | 0.25 | Zinc | -0.25 | 0.75 mg |
| 25.00 mcg | 20.00 | Manganese | -20.00 | 5.00 mcg |
| 75.00 mcg | -15.00 | Copper | 15.00 | 90.00 mcg |
| 15.00 mcg | 0.00 | Iodine | 0.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 2.80 mcg | 0.80 | Selenium | -0.80 | 2.00 mcg |
| 47.00 mg | 3.00 | Sodium | -3.00 | 44.00 mg |
| 110.00 mg | -8.00 | Potassium | 8.00 | 118.00 mg |
| 86.00 mg | 21.00 | Chloride | -21.00 | 65.00 mg |
Vitamins comparison
Vitamins from both formulas are listed in the center. If they exist in a formula they will have a value next to them. The difference will be show under the +/- column for easy visibility.
| Enfamil Nutramigen | +/- | Vitamin | +/- | Similac ProTotal Comfort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin A | 0.00 | 300.00 IU |
| 60.00 IU | 0.00 | Vitamin D | 0.00 | 60.00 IU |
| 2.00 IU | 0.50 | Vitamin E | -0.50 | 1.50 IU |
| 9.00 mcg | 1.00 | Vitamin K | -1.00 | 8.00 mcg |
| 80.00 mcg | -20.00 | Thiamin (Vit B1) | 20.00 | 100.00 mcg |
| 90.00 mcg | -60.00 | Riboflavin (Vit B2) | 60.00 | 150.00 mcg |
| 60.00 mcg | 0.00 | Vitamin B6 | 0.00 | 60.00 mcg |
| 0.30 mcg | 0.05 | Vitamin B12 | -0.05 | 0.25 mcg |
| 1000.00 mcg | -50.00 | Niacin | 50.00 | 1050.00 mcg |
| 16.00 mcg | 1.00 | Folic Acid | -1.00 | 15.00 mcg |
| 500.00 mcg | 50.00 | Pantothenic Acid | -50.00 | 450.00 mcg |
| 3.00 mg | -1.40 | Biotin | 1.40 | 4.40 mcg |
| 12.00 mg | 3.00 | Vitamin C | -3.00 | 9.00 mg |
| 24.00 mg | 0.00 | Choline | 0.00 | 24.00 mg |